2. Reactions to cold weather and extreme low temperatures can be seen through developmental adaptions and short term responses. Developmental adaptions are actual changes in the DNA of a population of individuals in response to a long-term stress (in this case, cold temperatures) to produce a phenotypic change through evolutionary forces. The population changes over generations.
- Heat Retention: More efficient than heat production because it requires less energy. Energy is obtained from dietary sources and unless food is abundant, any factor that conserves energy can be beneficial.
- Metabolic Rate Increase & Shivering: Increases in metabolic rate and shivering are short-term responses that generate body heat. Increases in metabolic rate (the rate at which cells break up nutrients) release energy in the form of heat. Shivering also generates muscle heat, as does voluntary exercise. As mentioned before, these actions pose a threat because large amounts of nutrients are required to provide more energy to complete these actions.
- Vasoconstriction: Another short-term response to extreme cold temperatures. Instead of producing heat like the previous mechanisms, it minimizes heat loss and therefore is more energy efficient. Vasoconstriction differs from vasodilation (used in extreme heat) as it restricts capillary blood flow to the surface of the skin, thus reducing heat loss at the body surface. Creating body heat is more economical than creating it, therefore vasoconstriction is very efficient in above freezing temperatures. However, if temperatures drop to below freezing levels, vasoconstriction can serve as a negative response which will ultimately lower the skin temperature to the point of frostbite or potentially worse.
- Weight & Height: In general, people exposed to chronic cold (the majority of the year) maintain higher metabolic rates than people who live in warmer climates. Diets that consist of high animal protein and fat diet serve to maintain high metabolic rates required by exposure to chronic cold. In general, the body shape tendency of populations living in cold climates is to be squat and round, allowing individuals to retain more heat in their body core.


3. There are many benefits of studying human variation from the perspective across environmental clines rather than basing it off of race. Through the use of clines, we are able to see how different races and species adapted to certain environmental stresses. A benefit to using information from explorations like this is that we can see natural selection in action. This information can be used in a productive way by helping us learn about learn more about the human species and how exactly they react and adapt to these stresses (heat, cold, high altitude, etc.)
4. In Biology, the term race refers to geographically pattern phenotypic variation within a species. Up until the twenty-first century, race was used to express human variation of environmental stresses, but now scientists study human variation over environmental clines. I can use race to understand the variation of the adaptations listed in #2 because certain races have specific habits and rituals, such as their diet and eating patterns (bullet 4; #2).
The study of environmental influences on adaptions is a better way to understand human variation than by the use of race because there is major limitation of traditional classification by means of race. These traditional ways are inherently typological thus categorizing things based on stereotypes or ideals that comprise a specific set of traits. These beliefs and typologies are often incorrect because any grouping made will always include some individuals that do not conform to every single aspects of a particular race.
Very interesting information! Vasoconstriction seemed really interesting. Our body can react in such ways without us even knowing it, and I just think that's so crazy.I read Natalie's post as well, and she talked about how the adaptation of height helps keep the body cool, and you mentioned that being short helps keep the body warm. Before this class, I didn't even know that that was an advantage. Nice post!
ReplyDeleteVery good summary of cold stress and I appreciate how you broke down the body's response into two primary response, conserving and producing heat.
ReplyDeleteIt was a little difficult to pull the four primary types of adaptations out of the second section.
Short term: Shivering and increasing metabolic rate. Understand that increasing the metabolic rate doesn't necessarily mean exercising. The body can do that over time if needed without an increase in physical activity.
Facultative: Vasoconstriciton actually falls into this category but as this will actually lead to cell death in surface tissues, the body eventually switches to alternative vasoconstriction/vasodilation to allow some circulation to the surface tissues.
Developmental: Populations in cold climates do tend to have higher metabolic rates. Think of it like turning up the furnace in colder climate. Costly in terms of the use of energy but effective as long as food intake can keep up, which is why high fat diets are useful among populations such as the Inuit. Body shape itself is a developmental trait, with short, round body shapes being more adaptive in cold climates. Check the information on Bergmann and Allen's rules in the assignment files.
Cultural adaptations: Missing this from your post.You have an image but no description or discussion.
"Through the use of clines, we are able to see how different races and species adapted to certain environmental stresses."
Part of the point of the assignment was to learn how race is NOT a useful way of studying human variation, so using that term here is not appropriate. Also, are their multiple species of extant humans? Or just one? It is better to talk about humans as 'populations', instead of races and certainly more accurate than using "species".
Learning more about how humans adapt is certainly useful, but can you offer a more concrete way this information can be used? Can information like this lead to medical advances or better technology?
Race has not origin in biology. At one time, long ago, it was believed to be biologically based, but no longer. Race is a subjective sociocultural system of organizing humans into categories, defined by superficial phenotypic differences, and that system of race is different across cultures. So which system should we use? None. None of them are based in biology, none of them have a causal relationship with human variation, and therefore cannot be used to objectively understand biological variation. The environment, on the other hand, does have a causal relationship with human variation, and can be used to understand why humans vary as they do.
Great job. I felt like I got a blast of facts that will prepare me for the final! I am so happy you included a picture and summary of vasoconstriction. I was going to put it in my post but I found it confusing. Your image and explanation helped clear this up for me. Thank you!
ReplyDelete